UNIT – 5
5A. MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
4A. 1 INTRODUCTION
Materials, as we know, means the raw materials used in the
manufacturing process to be transformed into
finished product. It is a well-known fact that no production work
is possible without materials. Also it has
been estimated that most of the manufacturing concerns spend more
than 60% of the money raw materials.
In other words, materials constitute a major portion of the money
we invest in production. In this
connections, it should be noted that there are so many problems
attached with the management of
materials such as investment in materials, storage and
obsolescence problems, under utilization and ideal
capacity of funds, which require immediate attention of the
management – that the cost of production may
be reduced to the minimum a the quality of he product may be
maintained.
5A. 2 DEFINITION
Materials management is the planning, directing, controlling and
co-coordinating of all those
activities concerned with materials and inventory requirements
from the point of their inception to their
introduction into the manufacturing process. It begins with determination
of materials quality and ends
with its issuance to productions in time to meet customers demand
on schedule at the lowest cost.
P Gopalakrishnan and M. Sundaresan define management as “the
function responsible for the
coordination of planning, sourcing, purchasing, moving, storing
and controlling materials in an optimum
manner so as to provide a pre decide service to the customer at a
minimum cost.
Bethel and others define the term materials management
“controlling me kind, amount, location,
movement and timing of the various commodities used in and
produced by the industrial enterprise.”
In general, materials management is a service function affecting
the flow of materials in a manner in which
it helps in conserving the materials cost, best utilization of
materials and maintaining the quality of both
incoming and outgoing materials. It covers all aspects pertaining
to a) Materials cost, b) materials supply
and c) Materials utilization.
Now, let us discuss the functions of materials management.
5A. 3 FUNCTIONS OF MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
Materials Manageemnt covers all aspects of materials and material
supply which are very important
for converting the raw materials and other inputs into the desired
finished products. The various functions
of the materials management are as follows:
a. Materials planning
b. Purchasing of Materials
c. Reducing store-keeping and warehousing
d. Inventory control
e. Standardization simplification and value Analysis
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
f. Transportation and material handling
g. Disposal of scrap surplus and obsolete materials
In the following paragraphs, let us discuss the importance of
materials management.
5A. 4 IMPORTANCE OF MATERIAL MANAGEMENT
A survey conducted by the directorate of Industrials Statistics
during 1954-57 showed that the
average material cost is 64% of the sales value. in some
industries, it costs up to 70%. These figures show
the importance of materials management. Materials has its
tentacles spread to all areas of production such
as men, machines and marketing. The concept of materials
management has been gaining importance
very gradually now-a-days. In concerns, avoidance of wastage is
very important for efficient utilization of
materials. Materials management helps to avoid wastage to a greater
extent. As emphasized earlier,
materials management is a service function and is of very great
importance to other sections like
manufacturing, marketing, engineering and finance by way of
providing assistance to these sections in
their operations. Also, materials management is of very great help
in efficient and judicious purchasing,
minimizing wastages in handling, storing and transporting the
materials and the utilization of materials
very efficiently. It is worth mentioning here that the materials
management contributes to the success or
failure of a concern. Form the national point of view, materials
management plays a pivotal role, for the
success of national plans, because efficient materials management
can exploit the national resources,
materials efficiency and according to the plans. In addition to
reducing material costs, efficient materials
management is useful for the following purposes. A) for reducing
foreign exchange by utilizing the
imported items, to their maximum value and thus helps in reducing
the imports b) by reducing the cost of
finished goods, and maintaining the quality, it is possible for
Indian manufacturing to compete better in
foreign market and earn more foreign exchange.
5A. 5 OBJECTIVES OF MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
The main objectives of materials management are as follows
(i) The first and foremost objective of materials management, as
discussed earlier, is to minimize the
materials cost thus paying the way for reducing the cost of the
product manufactured. The
company is able to maintain the price at a reasonable level.
(ii) It also aims at procuring and providing materials of desired
quality when enquired, at the lowest
possible overall cost of the concern.
(iii) It also aims at reducing investment tied-up in inventories
for use in other productive purposes and
to develop high inventory turn-over ratios.
(iv) The next objective of materials management is to purchase,
receive, transport and store materials
efficiently and to reduce the related costs.
(v) Continuous supply of materials is an essential pre-requisite
for uninterrupted production.
materials management aims at finding our new sources of supply and
to develop cordial elations
with the suppliers.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
(vi) The next objective of the materials management is to cut down
costs through simplification,
standardization, value Analysis, and import substitution etc.
(vii)Materials management aims at minimizing procedural delays in
procuring materials.
In nutshell, various important objects of materials management can
be summed up as follows:
1. To reduce material cost
2. For the efficient control of inventories which helps in
releasing the working capital for productive
purposes.
3. To ensure uniform flow of materials for production.
4. To ensure right quality of products at right place.
5. To establish and maintain cordial relation-ship with customer
6. To ensure economy in using the important items and to find
their substitutes.
7. To increase the profits of the concern
8. To contribute towards competitiveness and
9. To report changes in market conditions and other factors
affecting the concern, to the customers.
5A. 6 INTEGRATED MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
Management of Materials is one of the most important functions of
a business organisatoin. Its importance
may very from one industry to another but it is most important for
a manufacturing organisatoin as it is
directly linked with profitability. The successful management of
materials largely depends upon a)
adequate availability of funds b) proper procurement, storage and
utilization of materials c) effective
handling, dispatch and disposal of incoming and outgoing material.
In this connection, it should be noted
here that here that material management is not an individual or
isolated function in an organisation. It is a
combination of inter-related functions. It is a management
function having close links with all other fields
of a business enterprise, It has links with various aspects
connected with materials such as purchasing,
storage, inventory control, materials handling standardization
etc. Also, it covers a very wide field and
deals with the planning and programming of material and equipment,
market research for purchase,
procurement of material, packaging, storage and inventory control,
transportation of materials etc. To cite
an example, purchase of material should be done according to
production schedule with in turn should be
determined on the basis of the marketing capabilities. If we want
to change the design or appearance of
the product, the help of Design, Technical and Marketing
departments are very vital. Decrease and
increase in the volume of production affects the financial
position and ultimately affects all other activities
of the concern.
To be precise, Materials management may be said to be an activity
integrated and coordinated with such
widely dispersed functions of management as Budgeting, Purchasing,
Receiving, Production, Scheduling,
manufacturing maintenance, Inventory and Material Quality control
as also, Storage, warehousing,
shipping, traffic and it begins working from the very inception
stage of procurement of materials and then
getting the materials through successive stages of operations for
the final embodiment into an end
product and distribution.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Every organisation, or productions unit aims at a) decreasing the
cost b) increasing the profitability
and c) improved productivity. If any organisation want to attain
the above three objectives, we can easily
conclude that coordination and integration of all the activities
become essential. Also, in order to get the
desired results, i.e. maximization of profits and minimizing the
cost, the effective integrating of all the
inter – related segments are very essential. In this context,
integrated materials management is a function
which integrates all the above said activities to financing
storing and distributions for the efficient and
smooth functioning of an undertaking.
Let us now highlight the aims of Integrated Materials Managemnet.
5A. 7 AIMS OF INTEGRATED MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
An efficient and well-planned materials management programme
serves the following aims:
a. COST REDUCTION
To bring down the prices of any products, the management, as far
as possible, should try to
exercise care and diligence in purchase and issue of materials.
Efficient purchase of materials
would result in reduction of costs.
b. ELIMINATION OF WASTE
Elimination of water is a very essential phenomenon that a company
should adopt to ensure better
functioning of an enterprise. Wastages in receipt, issue, storage
and movement of materials should
be avoided. Laborers and employees are entrusted with these jobs
should be trained well to
exercise due care while at work.
C. COMPLETION OF WORK AS PER THE PRODUCTION SCHEDULE
Efficient Integrated Materials Management aims at completing the
production job according to the
pre-determined programme. Dislocation of production schedules lead
to unnecessary delay,
expenses and waste of time. IMM integrates and aims at sticking on
to the pre determined
production schedule. IMM programme controls production at every
step and stage of production.
5A. 8 ADVANTAGES OF INTEGRATED MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
A well coordinates IMM results in the following advantages both to
the department and concern in
general.
ADVANTAGE OF THE DEPARTMENT
1. Better Inventory Planning:
A well programmed IMM is a boon to Inventory Planning. Without
much loss of time Materials
department is in a position to know the quantum of existing
materials stock. Also, it is easy to find out
the future requirements of materials, stock to be kept in reserve
etc.
2. Faster Inventory Turnover:
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Both overstocking and/or understocking of materials is a dangerous
phenomenon in an organisation.
Not only, will it affect the smooth flow of material movement and
continuous productions, but it will
lock the capital without any better use which otherwise could have
been used for a better purpose.
Efficient Integrated Materials management helps to invest in an
optimum manner on it. Faster
inventory turnover brings about faster movement any cycling of
funds in the organisation.
3. Material availability:
As IMM functions in a phased and programmed manner, production
goes on without any interruption.
This is achieved through availability of materials as and when
required.
4. Efficient coordination:
IMM helps in the integration and coordination of all the
departments.
5. Better communication:
Communication means exchange of facts, ideas, opinions and
messages among persons.
Communications has a very distinct place in IMM as it decides the
success or failure of it. Thus IMM
improves the communications system in the organisation.
6. Improved productivity and Increased profitability:
Productivity which is one of the ultimate results of the IMM, is
achieved in a shorter period. Cost
reduction. Elimination of wastes and productivity indirectly lead
the concern to earn a higher profit.
ADVANTAGES TO THE ORGANISATION
Apart from the above advantages to the departments, IMM ensures
the following advantages to the
organisation:
1. Centralized authority and responsibility
IMM helps in centralizing the functions and duties pertaining to
materials. A centralized
organization always offers better accountability and responsibility.
Under centralized system duties
and responsibilities are clearly spelt out and works evenly
distributed. This helps in detecting the
errors and deficiencies of individual employees and workers.
2. Well coordinated efforts:
Under IMM, a well planned policy is installed. This ensures good
support and cooperation from all
who are working with him. Outside people dealing with the concern
also extend their hearty co for
the smooth conduct of the organisation.
3. Materials Manager benefited:
The material manager enjoys so many advantages after the
installation of IMM. A well planned IMM
helps him to predict the ales in a better way. It is also very
helpful for him to check out the
production plan efficiently. Material, requirements could easily
be identified with the help of IMM.
Various inventory levels such as Minimum Level, Maximum Level,
Reorder Level and Economic
Order Quantity can be easily fixed with the help of IMM. Better
purchasing, efficient physical
control of materials are some of the direct outcome of a
well-coordinated IMM .
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
4. Performance Evaluation:
A well installed IMM helps to evaluate the performance of
personnel attached to materials
department. The performance should be easily evaluated if the
organisatoin is able to achieve the
following. They are reduced lead time, reduced storage and
reservation cost, better communication
judicious and speedy solutions to problems pertaining to materials
department.
5A. 9 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS
Aggregate capacity plans develop strategies for employment levels
(man power) machinery and
utility, sub-contract and purchase and facility modification. The
planning horizon for aggregate capacity
plans usually very from six to eighteen months and short range
master production schedules (MPB) are
developed within the capacity constraints stipulated by aggregate
plans. The time horizon for short range
master production schedules vary from a few weeks to several
months and indicate the finished products
or end items to be manufactured. The entire resource requirements
planning system is based on the
master production schedules.
5A. 10 RESOURCE REQUIREMENTS PLANNING
Resource requirement planning is directed at the determination of
the amount and timing of production
resources such as personnel, materials, cash and production
capacity needed to produce the finished
products or end items as per the master production schedule.
Resource requirements planning is also known as rough-cut capacity
planning. It can be used to evaluate
the feasibility of a trial master production schedule. It is an
aggregate planning tool that is used to sum up
and evaluate the workload that a production plan (MPS) imposes
either on all work centres or on only
selected key work centres where resources are limited, expensive
or difficult to obtain from outside
sources (sub-contractors). This step ensures that a proposed MPS
does not overload any key work centres
or departments or machines thus making the MPS unworkable.
Rough-cut capacity planning is usually
applied to the critical work centres which are most likely to be
bottlenecks.
Steps involved in rough-cut capacity planning are:
1. Developing a trial production plan (or trial master production
schedule) that indicates the company’
s products that are planned for production during each week or
month of the planning horizon.
2. Computing the work load that this production plan will impose
on each key work centre and key
sub-contractors for each period (week or month) of the planning
horizon. The load profile i.e., the
load on each work centre over time, is evaluated for feasibility,
by comparing the load with the
available capacity in each of the key work centres or key
sub-contractors.
3. If the trial production plan does not appear to be feasible or
does not make optimal use of the
resources in the key work centres, the plan may be revised.
4. The capacity requirements of the revised production plan
(revised MPS) can then be evaluated to
determine the feasibility of the plan.
5. Step No. 4 and 5 are repeated until a plan considered to be
satisfactory is developed.
There are two main elements of resource requirements planning
systems namely
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
(a) Material requirements planning (MRP)
(b) Capacity requirements planning (CRP)
5A. 11 MATERIAL REQUIREMENTS PLANNING (MRP OR MRP-1)
For a manufacturing company to produce end items to meet demands,
the availability of sufficient
production capacity must be co-ordinate with the availability of
all raw materials and purchased items
from which, the end items are to be produced. In other words,
there is a need to manage the availability of
dependent demand items from which the products are made.
Dependent-demand items are the
components i.e. materials or purchased items, fabricated parts or
sub-assemblies that make up the end
product.
One approach to manage the availability of dependent-demand items
is to keep a high stock of all the
items that might be needed to produce the end items and when the
on-hand stock dropped below a
present re-order level, the items are produced or bought as the
case may be to replenish the stock to the
maximum level. However, this approach is costly due to the
excessive inventory of components, fabricated
parts and sub-assemblies to ensure high service level (i.e. availability
of dependent demand items at a
short notice)
An alternative approach to managing dependent-demand items is to
plan for procurement or manufacture
of the specific components that will be required to produce the
required quantities of end products as per
the production schedule indicated by the master production
schedule (MPS). The technique is known as
material requirements planning (MRP) technique.
MRP is a computer-based system in which the given MPS is exploded
into the required amounts of raw
materials, parts and sub-assemblies, needed to produce the end
items in each time period (week or month)
of the planning horizon. The gross requirement of these materials
is reduced to net requirements by
taking into account the materials that are in inventory or on
order.
A schedule of orders is developed for purchased materials and
in-house manufactured items over the
planning horizon based on the knowledge of lead items for
procurements or in-house production.
5A. 12 OBJECTIVES OF MRP
The objectives of material requirements planning in operations
management are:
1. To improve customer service by meeting delivery schedules
promised and shortening delivery lead
times.
2. To reduce inventory costs by reducing, inventory levels.
3. To improve plant operating efficiency by better use of
productive resources.
Three facts of MRP technique are:
a) The MRP technique as a requirements calculator
b) MRP – A manufacturing, planning and control system
c) MRP – A manufacturing resourced planning system.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
The MRP technique as a requirements calculator was originally used
as an inventory control tool, providing
reports that specify how many components should be ordered, when
they should be ordered and when
they should be procured or produced in-house. Since MRP is a
computer-based system, it was possible to
expand the system into a manufacturing planning and control system
by providing information for
planning and controlling both the material and the capacity
required to manufacture the products. Hence,
MRP serves as a key component in an information system for
planning and controlling production
operations and procurement of materials. It is the basic
foundation for production activity control or shop
floor control, for vendor follow-up systems and for detailed
capacity requirements planning. When both
the MRP and CRP are integrated within one system, the system is
known as “Materials Requirements
Planning”, abbreviated as “MRP” or MRP-1. When MRP is extended to
include feed-back from and control
of vendor orders and production operations, it is called
‘closed-loop MRP’ which helps managers achieve
effective manufacturing control.
When the capabilities of closed-loop MRP are extended top
integrate financial, accounting, personnel,
engineering and marketing information along with the production
planning and control activities of the
basic MRP system, the resulting broad-based resource-coordination
system is known as manufacturing
resource planning or MRP-II. MRP-II is the heart of corporate management
information system for many
companies, as it provides information about inventory investment
levels, plant expansion needs, and
work-force requirements that is useful for coordinating,
financial, engineering and manufacturing efforts
to achieve the company’s overall business plans.
The projections of what materials and components will be purchased
and when, can be used to develop
purchase commitments and a projected purchasing budget. The labour
hours projected in the capacity
requirement plant for each work centre, can be aggregated to
develop personnel needs and labour
budgets. The projected on-hand inventory of material can be used
to develop inventory budgets.
5A. 13 GENERAL OVERVIEW OF MRP
Basically, MRP consists of a set of computer programs hat are run
periodically (once a week or once a
month) to incorporate the latest schedule of production
requirements MRP performs three important
functions viz.
Order planning and control, i.e. when to release orders and for
what quantity?
Priority planning and control i.e., comparison of expected date of
availability with the need date of
each item.
Provision of a basis for planning capacity requirements and
development of broad business plans.
MRP is applicable primarily to companies that carry out the fabrication
of parts and assembly of standard
products in batch quantities.
The entire MRP system is driven by the MRP. The bill of materials
file and inventory status file are fed in to
the MRP computer program to generate the output.
5A. 14 MRP SYSTEM INPUTS
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
FIGURE : 5.1 ‘MRP’ STRUCTURE
1. MASTER PRODUCTION SCHEDULE (MPS)
The MPS specifies what end products are to be produced and when.
The planning horizon should be long
enough to cover the cumulative lead times of all components that
must be purchased or manufactured to
meet the end product requirements.
2. BILL OF MATERIAL FILE (BOM) OR PRODUCT STRUCTURE FILE
This file provides the information regarding all the materials,
parts and sub-assemblies that go into the
end product. The Bill of Materials can be viewed as having a
series of levels, each of which represents a
stage in the manufacture of the end product. The highest level (or
zero level) of the BOM represents the
final assembly or end product. The BOM file identifies each
component by a unique part number and
facilities processing the end product requirements into component
requirements.
3. INVENTORY STATUS FILE
The inventory status file gives complete and up-to-date
information on the on-hand quantities, gross
requirements, scheduled receipts and planned order releases for
the item. It also includes other
information such as lot sizes, lead times, safety stock levels and
scrap allowances, etc. The gross
requirements are total needs from all resources whereas the net
requirements are ‘net’ after allowing for
available inventory and scheduled receipt. Scheduled receipts are
quantities already on order from a
vendor or in house shop. Planned receipts are quantities that will
be ordered on a vendor or in-house shop.
Planned order release indicates the quantities and date to
initiate the purchase or manufacture of
materials that will be received on schedule after the lead time
offset.
5A. 15 MRP SYSTEM OUTPUT
Two primary outputs are:
1. Planned order schedule which is a plan of the quantity of each
material to be ordered in each time
period. The order may be a purchase order on the suppliers or
production orders for parts and
sub-assembles on production departments.
2. Changes in planned orders – i.e., modification of previous
planned orders. The secondary output
are:
1. Exception reports which list items requiring management
attention to control
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
2. Performance reports regarding how well the system is operating
– e.g. inventory
turnovers, percentage of delivery promises kept and stock out
incidences.
3. Planning reports such as inventory forecasts, purchase
commitment reports, etc.
5A. 16 DEFINITIONS OF TERMS USED IN MRP SYSTEM
1. MASTER PRODUCTION SCHEDULE (MRP): This is the schedule of the
quantity and timing of all end
products to be produced over a specific planning horizon. MPS is
developed from customer’s firm
orders or from forecasts of demand or both. It is an input to the
MRP system.
2. PRODUCT STRUCTURE: Indicates the level of components required
to produce an end product.
3. BILLS OF MATERIAL: A list indicating the quantities of all raw
materials, parts, components, sub
assemblies and major assemblies that go into an end product. It
gives details of the build up of a
product. It may also be called as indented parts list.
4. BILLS OF MATERIAL FILE: A bills of material file, also known as
product-structure file, is a
computerized file listing all finished products, the quantity of
raw materials, parts sub-assemblies
and assemblies in each product. The bills of materials file must
be kept up-to-date as and when
the products are redesigned or modified with addition/deletion of
some parts, components and
sub-assemblies.
5. INVENTORY STATUS FILE: It is a computerized file with a comprehensive
record of each and every
material held in inventory. The information included in this file
are, materials on hand or on order,
planned orders, planned order releases, allocated materials, lot
sizes, lead times, safety stock
levels, costs and suppliers for each material. The inventory file
must kept up-to-date taking into
consideration the daily inventory transactions such as receipts,
issues, scrapped materials, planned
orders and order releases.
6. MRP COMPUTER PROGRAM: It is a computer program, which processes
the MRP information. Its
inputs are the MPS, inventory status file and bills of materials
file. The primary outputs are: planned
order schedule, planned order releases and changes to planned
orders.
7. AVAILABLE INVENTORY: Materials that are held in inventory of
which are on order, but are not
either safety stock or allocated to other uses.
8. ALLOCATED INVENTORY: Materials that are held in inventory or on
order but which have been
allocated to specific production orders
9. ON-HAND INVENTORY: The quantity of a material, physically held
in inventory at a point of time. It
may include safety stock and allocated inventory except materials
on order.
10. PLANNING HORIZON: The number of time periods (days, weeks or
months) included in the MPS,
CRP, MRP and departmental schedules.
11. ACTION BUCKET: The unit of time measurement in MRP systems. It
is a particular period of time in
the planning horizon. For example, Bucket # 10 means the tenth
period (usually a week in duration)
of the planning horizon.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
12. GROSS REQUIREMENTS: The total quantity of an item at the end
of a period to meet the panned
output levels, not considering any availability of the item in
inventory or scheduled receipts.
13. SCHEDULED RECEIPTS: The quantity of an item that will be
received at the beginning of a time
period from a supplier as a result of orders already placed (open
orders).
14. PLANNED ORDER RECEIPTS: The quantity of an item that is
planned to be ordered so that, it will be
received at the beginning of the time period to meet the net
requirements for that time period. The
order is yet to be placed.
15. PLANNED ORDER RELEASES: The quantity of an item that is
planned to be ordered and the planned
time period for releasing this order, so that, the item will be
received when needed. This time
schedule is determined by off-setting the planned order receipts
schedule to allow for lead times.
When this other is released, it becomes a schedule receipt.
16. NET REQUIREMENTS: The quantity of an item that must be
procured to meet the scheduled output
for the period.
17. LOW-LEVEL CODING: It is the coding of each material at the
lowest level in ay product structure
that it appears. A component can appear at more than one level in
the product structure. Because
MRP computer programs process net requirements calculations for
all products, level by level from
end items, down to the raw materials, low level coding avoids
redundant net requirements
calculations.
18. LOT-SIZING DECISIONS: Whenever there is a need for the net
requirement of a material, a decision
must be taken regarding the quantity of material to be ordered
(either purchase order or
production order). Lot-sizing decisions include both the batch or
lot-size (quantity) as well as the
timing of these lots.
19. DEPENDENT DEMAND: Demand for raw material, part or a
component, that is dependent on the
demand for the end product in which these materials are used.
20. INDEPENDENT DEMAND: Demand for a materials that is independent
of the demands for other
materials. For example, demand for end products re independent of
demand for parts, raw
materials or components as their demands are determined, by
customers outside the organizations.
21. LUMPY DEMAND: If the demand for the materials varies greatly
from time period o time period (say
week to week), the demand is said to be ‘lumpy demand’.
22. CAPACITY REQUIREMENT PLANNING: The process of reconciling the
Master Production Schedule to
the available capacities of production departments (viz., machine and
labour capacities) over the
planning horizon.
23. PLANNED ORDER RELEASES: Number in ‘planned order releases’ row
indicate when orders should
be placed to meet the requirement for the item. The time period at
which the order should be
released is found by subtracting the lead time from the ‘net
requirement’ period (this procedure is
called ‘offsetting’ by lead time)
5A. 17 ISSUES IN MRP
Some of the issues which deserve consideration in any
comprehensive treatment of MRP are:
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
1. Lot-sizing
2. Safety stock
3. Scrap allowances
4. Pegging
5. Cycle counting
6. Updating
7. Time fence
The above issues are discussed below:
1. LOT-SIZING: The MRP system generates planned order releases,
which trigger purchaser order for
outside suppliers or production orders (or work orders) for
in-house production departmens. As
certain costs such as the set-up cost (or ordering cost) and
holding cost (or inventory carrying cost)
are associated with each order, it is necessary to consider the trade
off between thse two types of
costs and take decision regarding how much to order (i.e., batch
size/lot-size) A question that
should be examined is whether there is some economic lot-size (EOQ
or EBQ) that should be
purchased or produced as the case may be. In production, a minimum
lot-size is sometimes
established to reduce the set-up cost per unit produced. Such
minimum lot-sizes may cause
excessive inventory, if it exceeds very much the net requirement
of a period and followed by
periods with no requirements, which is counter to the benefit of
the MRP system.
VARIOUS METHODS OF LOT –SIZING ARE:
(a) Lot-for-lot ordering (LFL) in which quantity equal the net
requirement for a given period. Separate
orders are released for each period’s net requirement.
(b) EOQ technique in which the order quantity is larger than a
single period’s net requirement so that,
ordering cost and holding costs balance out.
(c) Requirements may be batched until they reach some arbitrary
minimum order size. If the
requirement exceeds this minimum, the requirement will determine
the order size.
(d) The lot size may be determined by the period order quantity
(POQ) technique. The ordering policy
is to order the net requirements of the number of periods equal to
the EOQ.
(e) The lot size can be chosen to approximately balance ordering
and holding costs. One method of
doing this is known as part-period method or part-period algorithm
(PPA). This is a simple
approach to the lot-size selection when a series of requirements
which are not necessary uniform,
are to be batched into orders so that the total cost will be near
the minimum. This method does
not provide an optimal lot-size (i.e., EOQ) but it approaches
optimality by attempting to make
holding cost for a lot, nearly equal to the ordering cost for the
lot.
Unlike the EOQ model, the part algorithm method may select a
different quantity to be ordered
each time the order is to be placed. The PPA assumes that an order
will be scheduled in the first period in
which, there is a net requirement. The requirement for the next
period is added into this order, if the cost
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
of holding these units until they are used, is less than the cost
of receiving them as a separate order.
Requirements for future periods continue to be added to the lot
until the total holding cost for the
incomes a close as possible to the order cost without dividing a
period’s requirement.
2. SAFETY STOCK: There are divergent views by MRP users regarding
whether safety stock should be
used MRP systems or not. One side of argument supporting the use
of safety stock is that, it
performs the function of avoided excessive stock –outs caused by
uncertain lead times and daily
demands. On the other hand, those who oppose the use of safety
stocks in MRP, argue that, safety
stock is not required because MRP systems adapt to changing
conditions that affect demand and
lead times.
The use of safety stock can be justified only by the sources of
uncertainty, present during lead
times. Safety stock is normally maintained for end items which
have independent demand. For lower-level
items such as raw material and parts, the uncertainty of demand is
adequately controlled, because the
demand is a dependent demand which is set by the MRP. However,
uncertainties may be present during
lead times because of uncertainty of the lead time and the
uncertainty of demand that occurs because of
changes in the MPS. Keeping some safety stock can be justified for
raw materials, parts and other
low-level items, although at significantly reduced levels.
3. SCRAP ALLOWANCES : The bill of materials explosion could
include multiplication by a factor (more
than one) to make an allowance for the usual scrap loss in
manufacturing an item.
4. PEGGING: Pegging is a technique which enables the planner to
trace from a work load in a work
centre, back through its higher-level assemblies to determine,
what end item in the MPS caused the
load. Single level pegging is used often, which simply tells the
immediately higher-level parent of a
component. When materials plans are disrupted, pegging helps to
identify which components are
affected by such disruption. Pegging shows the level-by-level
linkages among components and
their time-phased status in MRP records. Pegging showing the
current records for an end item ‘X’
and for its sub components Y and Z at two lower level in the
product structure.
Similarly, if the master production schedule were to increase week
7’s gross requirements for X
from 20 to 60 to meet a special customer order, the pegging
procedure traces down through the
MRP records to identify associated changes at lower levels. The
planned order release of X in week
6 has to be raised from 40 to 60 and the associated requirements
for Y and Z, has to be changed
accordingly.
5. CYCLE COUNTING: Cycle counting is the process of counting
on-hand inventories at regular
intervals to verify inventory of components including defective
items at each stage of production
and in storage areas. This ensures that on-hand inventories tally
with the quantities shown in the
MRP records Based on cycle counting, the MRP records are updated
daily or weekly to show the
actual inventory status. This knowledge of actual inventory is
helpful in adjusting the production
schedules at various work centres.
6. UPDATING: Whenever changes occur in MPS, in inventory status
file, (e.g., revised lead times) or in
product structure file, or changes in product design occurs, the
MRP system must be updated. Two
approaches to update MRP system are
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
(a) Regenerative method which is a process used to update the MRP
at regular intervals by
reprocessing the entire set of information and regenerating the
entire MRP
(b) Net change method in which only those portions of the previous
MRP directly impacted by
informational changes are reprocessed. Transactions are entered
into a net change MRP
program frequently to reflect conditions as they change.
7. TIME PERIOD: It is a length of time that must elapse without
changing the MPS to stabilize the MRP
system. The MPS may be changed only after this time period. The
time fence is the shortest lead
time form raw material to finished production for an end item.
Within the time fence, the MPS
becomes frozen and the planned order releases become firm planned
orders.
5A. 18 Potential benefits from ‘MRP’
MRP is not just a way of calculating how much material to order
and when; but it is a new way of
managing manufacturing operations. MRP is a decision support
system or managerial information system,
which provides timely and valuable information to operations
managers.
When properly developed and implement, MRP can provide the
following benefits to the firm:
(1) INVENTORY: The information provided by the MRP system is
useful to better coordinate orders for
components with production plans for parent items. This results in
reduced levels of average inventory for
dependent-demand items (i.e., raw materials and work-in-process).
(2) PRODUCTION: Information from MRP facilitates better
utilization of human and capital resources.
Because of more accurate priority information from MRP, it is
possible to improve delivery performance. It
can also improve flow of work, thereby reducing intermittent
delays and reducing the manufacturing cycle
time for the jobs.
3. SALES: MRP helps to check in advance whether the desired
delivery dates are achievable. It improves the
company’s ability to react to change in customer orders, improves
customer service by helping production,
meet assembly dates and helps cut delivery lead times.
4. ENGINEERING: MRP helps in planning the time of design releases
and design changes.
5. PLANNING: MRP can simulate changes in the MPS for the purpose
of evaluations of alternative MPS. It
facilitates the projection of equipment and facility requirements,
workforce planning and procurement
expenses for a proposed MPS.
6. PURCHASING: MRP helps the purchase departments by making known
the real priorities and
recommending changes in due dates for orders so that the purchase
staff may expedite or delay the
orders placed on vendors. Because of this, the vendor relations
can be improved.
7. SCHEDULING: Better scheduling can result from MRP through
better knowledge of priorities.
8. FINANCE: MRP can help better planning of cash flow
requirements. It can identify time capacity
constraints or bottleneck work centres, there by helping
operations managers to make better capital
investment decisions.
5A. 19 IMPLEMENTATION OF MRP
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Successful implementation of MRP depends on the following factors:
1. MANAGEMENT COMMITMENT: Top level managers and other managers in
all parts of the organization
that will be affected by MRP must be aware of the efforts needed
to achieve the new way of managing
other activities.
2. USER INVOLVEMENT: A team consisting of people from all those
parts of the company that will use the
MRP system, will be responsible for the development and
implementation of the MRP. This will ensure
that the participation of users of he system in its development
will make them more familiar with the
system and its use.
3. EDUCATION AND TRAINING: All the people who work with the MRP
system must understand it an must
know how to use it. They must know what information to provide and
how to provide it, what
information to ask and how to obtain it. Hence, it is necessary
that all people connected with the MRP
system must be trained in its application and use.
4. SELECTION OF PACKAGES: the potential user must be able to
decide about the use of the net change
or regenerative MRP package, knowing their advantages and
disadvantages. Also the user must decide
whether to develop his own programs for MRP system or to purchase
and adapt the available package.
5. DATA ACCURACY: After a MRP system is installed, careful
attention and discipline must always be
exercised to ensure that all data used by the system are accurate.
Managers must exert effort to see
that, accurate and timely data are supplied to the system.
6. RELEASING MPS: The MPS developed should be realistic and
achievable. The MPS should not overload
the plant capacity. The company must develop MPS that effectively
users its capacity without causing
bottlenecks or overloads.
5A. 20 Problems in using MRP
1. MPS: Preparations of MPS, which is realistic in the midst of
uncertainties in market environment and
non-availability of adequate lead time form customers for delivery
of end products. Frequent
changes in MPS aggravate the problem.
2. MAINTAINING ACCURATE BOM FILES: Changes incorporated in BOM by
the design department
should be communicated to all users of BOM.
3. INCORRECT STOCK (INVENTORY) STATUS: A major problem is to know
the correct status of all
materials at all stages. Incorrect stock status results in an
erroneous net requirement of materials.
4. UNREALISTIC LEAD TIMES: Most crucial step in the MRP system
which minimizes inventory is the
time-phasing of requirements and release of orders; advancing by
the lead time required, so that,
materials arrive just when required.
5A. 21 PROBLEMS IN DESIGNING THE MRP SYSTEM
Inadequacies of software chosen
Deficient system design
Improper and untimely information flow among various related
departments.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
5A. 22 SOLUTION TO MRP DESIGN PROBLEMS
Solution to overcome the above problems in the design of MRP system
are:
1. Careful choice of software package to suit organization’s
specific needs.
2. Careful planning of activities and scheduling
3. Assigning work to competent man-power.
4. Continuous monitoring of progress against schedule.
5. Substantial education and training at all levels.
6. Involvement of users at the systems design stage itself.
7. Maximum attention at the stage of creating the database.
5A. 23 PROBLEMS IN MANAGING THE MRP SYSTEM:
1. Need for formal systems and role of systems
2. Need for proper organization of function viz., production
planning and control, materials,
production, quality, engineering
3. Importance of proper appreciation of planning and control
systems production and Operations
Management
4. Timeliness of generating information required in managing the
plant
5. Effective communication system
6. Proper motivation of people concerned with the implementation
of the system
7. Right leadership
5A. 24 EVALUATION OF MRP
The advantages of the MRP system over conventional
inventory-planning approaches viz., fixed
order quantity system (Q system) and fixed order-point system (P
system) are:
Improved customer services,
Reduced inventory level and
Improved operating efficiencies of production departments.
However, MRP systems cannot be used in all the production systems.
Conventionally, MRP is applied
only to manufacturing systems which process discrete products for
which BOM can be generated. MRP
is seldom used in service systems viz., petroleum refineries,
retailing systems, transportation firms and
other non-manufacturing systems.
5A. 25 CHARACTERISTICS OF ‘MRP’ SYSTEM
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
The production systems suitable for MRP should have the following
desirable.
CHARACTERISTICS:
1. An effective computer system.
2. Computerized BOM files and inventory status file for all end
products and materials with the
highest possible accuracy.
3. A production system that manufactures discrete products made up
of raw materials, parts,
sub-assemblies and major assemblies which are processed through
several production steps or
operations.
4. Production processes or operations requiring long processing
times.
5. Short and reliable lead times for procurement of raw materials
and components from vendors.
6. The time fence for the frozen MPS should be sufficient to
procure materials without undue
expediting effort.
7. Support and commitment of the top management.
MRP is more useful in process-focused systems that have long
processing times and complex
multi-stage production steps. It simplifies production and
inventory planning in process-focused
systems by its ability to offset planned order receipts to planned
order releases to account for long
lead times for in-house processed items or raw materials and
components purchased from suppliers.
For MRP to be effective supplier lead times must be short and
reliable and the MPS must be frozen
before the start of actual production to the MPS. What is to be
produce (i.e., the MPS) must be known
with certainty and quantity and timing of receipts of raw materials
and components must be
dependable? MRP offers advantages in inventory planning when
lot-sizes are small and demand is
highly variable.
However, it should be remembered that MRP is not a panacea to
solve all our inventory planning
problems. Basically, MRP is a computerized information system for
production and operations
managers MRP will not be of much help when computer systems are
ineffective, inventory status and
BOM files are inaccurate and MPS are unrealistic. MRP is best
applied when production systems are well
managed and when a comprehensive production and inventory planning
system is needed.
5A. 26 Manufacturing resource planning (MRP II)
Manufacturing Resource Planning (MRP II) has been developed by
manufacturing manages to
address the planning and controlling of a manufacturing process
and all of is related support functions. It
encompasses logically correct planning and control activities
related to materials, capacity, finance,
engineering, sales and marketing. MRP II is universally applicable
to any manufacturing organization,
regardless of its size, location, product or process.
MRP II is a management process for taking the business plan and
breaking it down into specific,
detailed tasks that people evaluate, agree upon and are held accountable
for. It involves all departments
viz., materials departments, engineering department that must
maintain bill of materials, sales/marketing
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
department that must keep sales plan up to date, purchasing and
manufacturing departments that must
meet due dates for bought-out items and in-house manufactured
items respectively.
From MRP I to MRP II: Manufacturing resourced planning (MRP II) is
a natural outgrowth of materials
requirements planning (MRP I). Whereas, MRP I focuses upon
priorities of materials, CRP is concerned with
time. Both material and time requirement are integrated within the
MRP system (i.e., MRP I). Beyond this,
MRP II has been coined to ‘close the loop’ by integrating
financial, accounting, personnel, engineering and
marketing information along with the production planning and
control activities of basic MRP systems.
MRP II is the heart of the corporate management information system
for many manufacturing firms.
5A. 27 Evolution of MRP II
The earlier resource requirement planning systems were quite
simple and unsophisticated. The
MRP technique was used for its most limited capability to
determine what materials and components are
needed, how many are needed and when they are needed and when they
should be ordered so that, they
are likely to be available when needed. In other words, MRP simply
exploded the MPS into the required
materials and was conceived as an inventory control tool or a
requirements calculator. Later, the logic of
MRP technique was extended to serve as the key component in an
information system for planning and
controlling production operation and purchasing. It was helpful to
production and operations manage to
determine the relative priorities of shop orders and purchase
orders. As a manufacturing planning and
control system, MRP laid the basic foundation for production
activity control or shop-floor control.
Closed-Loop MRP: Later, during the 1970s, closing the loop in MRP
systems was thought of by
experts in manufacturing management. The term “closed-loop MRP”
means ‘A system built around
material requirement planning (MRP I) and also including
additional planning functions such as master
production scheduling and capacity requirement planning’. Once the
planning phase is complete and plans
have been accepted as realistic and attainable, execution
functions such as shop-floor control function
(viz., input-output measurement, detailed scheduling, dispatching,
anticipated delay reports from shops
and vendors, purchase follow-up and control etc.) same into the
picture. The closed-loop MRP system
implies that, not only the above elements included in the system,
but also that there is feed back from the
execution functions so that, planning can be kept valid at al
times. Further to the closed – loop MRP
systems, the MRP I was improved to manufacturing resource planning
(MRP II).
Manufacturing resource planning is a broader resource
co-ordination system. In this, the
capabilities of closed-loop MRP are extended to provide
information on financial resources, personnel and
labour budgets. It provides a means of simulating to provide
information on the use of various assured
plans. Information about inventory investment levels, plant
expansion needs and work force requirements
is useful for coordinating marketing, finance, engineering and
manufacturing efforts to achieve the overall
business plan of the firm. MRP II is a direct outgrowth and
extension of the closed – loop MRP.
5A. 28 INTEGRATED SYSTEM
MRP II is an integrated system for planning and control. In this
process, a production plan is
developed from a business plan to specify production levels for
each months for each produt line for the
next one to five years. Once the produtoin plan is accepted by all
the functional departments, it becomes a
commitment for all concerned i.e. the production department is
expected to produce at he committed
levels, the sales department to sell at these levels and the
finance department to ensure adequate financial
resources for these levels of production. based on the production
plan, the MPS specified the quantities of
specific products to be produced every week. Rough-Cut capacity
planning is done to determine whether
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
the capacity available is roughly adequate to sustain the proposed
MRP. The MPS is then used to generate
material requirements and priority schedules for production. then
detailed capacity planning is done to
determine whether the capacity is sufficient for producing
specific components at each work centre,
during the scheduled time periods. After a realistic
capacity-feasible schedule is developed, the plan is
executed. Purchase schedule and shop floor schedules are
generated, based on which work centre
loadings, shop floor control and vendor follow-up activities can
be determined to ensure that the MPS is
met.
************
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
5B. INVENTORY CONTROL
5B. 1 INVENTORY
Inventory is a detailed list of movable goods such as raw
materials, work-in-progress, finished
goods, spares tools, consumables, general supplies which are
necessary to manufacture product and to
maintain the plant and machinery in good working condition. The
list includes the quantity and value of
each and every item, Inventory is defined as an idle resource of
any kind having an economic value since
these resources are idle when kept in the stores.
5B. 2 TYPES OF INVENTORIES
The inventories most firms hold can be classified into one of the
following types:
(i) Raw materials and purchased parts: These include, the raw
materials directly used for production
and the semi finished products – which are produced and supplied
by another firm and sold as a
raw materials by the firm under considerations.
(ii) In – process inventories (or) partially completed goods (or)
goods in transit are the semi finished
goods at various stages of the manufacturing cycle.
(iii) Finished goods inventories (manufacturing firms) or
merchandise (retail stores) are the finished
goods lying in the storage yards after the final inspection clearance
and waiting dispatch.
(iv) Indirect inventories include lubricants, spares, tools,
Consumables, component parts and general
supplies needed for proper operation, repair and maintenance
during the manufacturing cycle.
5B. 3 FUNCTIONS OF INVENTORY
Good inventory managemnet is important to the successful operation
of most organisatoin.
Adequate inventory facilitates smooth production operations and
help to assure customers for various
goods and services offered by the company. On the other hand,
carrying inventories ties up working
capital on goods that are kept idle – not earning any return on
investment. Hence the major problem of
inventory management is to maintain adequate but not excessive
levels of inventories. By holding the
optimum inventory, the following functions can be realized.
(i) To meet the expected customer (immediate and seasonal)
demands. A customer can be a person
who walks in off the street to buy some cosmetics say, a tooth
paste, and if a particular brand
he/she is asking for is not available then they may switchover to
some other brand. In this process,
the company losses sale opportunity. In most cases, expected
demand requirements are based on
forecasts.
(ii) To smoothen production requirements and establish an
efficient production flow, the organizations
often build up inventories in anticipation of seasonal increase in
demand, and take up the
production to replenish the depleted inventory during the
off-season periods.
(iii) To decouple internal operations: A buffer oil in-process
inventory will be created at successive
operations. If this is not created, a breakdown in any one
operation will cause the entire system to
come to a grinding halt.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
(iv) Desired quantities are purchased to protect the firm against
the effects of process changes and
possible stock-outs. Delayed deliveries and unexpected increases
in demand increase the risk of
shortages. Delays can be due to weather conditions, supplier
stock-outs, delivery of wrong and
defective materials. The risk of shortage can often be reduced by
holding stocks in excess.
(v) To take advantage of economic lot sizes in order to minimize
frequent ordering costs, it is
necessary to buy quantities that exceed the immediate usage
requirements. This necessitates
strong some or all of the purchased items for later use.
Similarly, it is economical to produce items
in batches which are generally in large quantities. Here also, the
excess finished goods must be
stored for firm to buy and produce in economic lot sizes without
having to try to match purchases
or production with demand requirements in the short run.
(vi) To derive advantages against price increases: If the firm
expects the prices of raw material or any
other input material to go up due to price revision by the
suppliers or due to changes of policy by
the government, they procure these items in excess of their
requirements. Similarly if they expect
the demand (due to seasonality) or price of the firm’s finished
good to go up, they produce the
items in excess and stock them thereby increasing the firm’s
profit.
(vii)Facilitate the production of different products using the
same facilities: If two or more products can
be manufactured using, the existing facilities of a firm, batch
processing form of production may
be adopted, thereby first produce on product in excess of the
current demand and store it for
future use. Then take up other product and adopt the same mode of
production so that the firm
will be able to produce more than one product and serve its
clients in a better way.
5B. 4 REPLENISHMENT OF STOCK
A firm which is already in the process of manufacturing a
particular product or products will have a
certain type of inventories of required quality and in desired
quantities. Adequate control has to be
exercised on the stock. If the control becomes inadequate, it will
result in either under stocking or
overstocking of items. Under stocking results in missed
deliveries, lost sales dissatisfied customers and
production bottlenecks while overstocking unnecessarily ties up
funds that might be used more
productively elsewhere in the case of continuous process industry,
under stocking will cease the
production line.
FIGURE: 5.2 DEMAND – LEAD RELATIONSHIP
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Enormous effort and resources are required to re-start the
production. in the case of overstocking,
the major consideration has to be given to the cost of carrying
the inventory. To achieve balance with
stock replenishment decision-avoiding both under stocking and overstocking,
fundamental decisions must
be made relates to the timing and size of the orders (i.e. when to
order and how much to order). This can
be better decided by making forecasts on the material
requirements.
5B. MATERIAL DEMAND FORECASTING
FIGURE : 5.3 ‘P’ SYSTEM OF INVENTORY
FIGURE : 5.4 ‘Q’ TYPE OF INVENTORY
Since inventories will be used to satisfy the demand requirements,
it is essential to have reliable estimates
of b amount and timing of demand requirements. Similarly, it is
essential to know how long it will take for
orders to be delivered. In addition, it is necessary to know the
extent to which demand and lead times
might vary: the more potential variability, greater the need for
additional stock to insure against as
between deliveries. Thus, there is a crucial link between
forecasting and inventory management.
5B. 6 TOOLS OF INVENTORY CONTROL
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
5B. 7 ABC ANALYSIS
FIGURE : 5.5 ‘ABC’ ANALYSIS
This is one of the basic analytical management tool which enables
top management to place the
effort where the results will be greatest. This technique tries to
analyze the distribution of an characteristic
by money value of importance in order to determine its priority.
The annual materials consumption
analysis of an organisation would indicate that a handful of high
value items-less than 10 percent of the
total number will account for a substantial portion of about 70-75
percent of the total consumption value,
and these few vital items are called ‘A’ items which needs careful
attention of the materials manager.
Similarly, large number of bottom’ items over 70 percent of the
total number called the trivial many
– account for about 10 percent of the total consumption value, and
are known as the ‘C’ class. The items
that lie between he top and bottom are called the ‘B’ category
items.
5B. 8 PROCEDURAL STEPS OF ‘ABC’ ANALYSIS
a) Identify all the items used by a company
b) List all the items as per their money value in the descending
order. i.e. The high valued
items will be listed first followed by the next valued item.
c) Count the number of high valued, medium valued and low valued
items
d) Calculate the individual values of the high, medium and low
valued items. This is arrived at
first by multiplying the number of items as in step and
(a) Their values as in step (b) and adding all the items in
different categories high,
medium and low.
e) Find the percentage of high, medium and low valued items. High
valued items normally
contribute for 70 percent or so of the total inventory cost and
medium and low valued items
20 and 10 percent respectively.
f) A graph can be plotted between percent of items and percent of
total inventory cost.
5B. 9 PURPOSE OF ABC ANALYSIS
The object of carrying out ABC analysis is to develop policy
guidelines for selective control. After
the analysis, broad policy guidelines can be established.
A. Items High Consumption Value
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
B. Items : Moderate Value
C. Items : Low Consumption Value
5B. 10 ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ABC ANALYSIS
This approach helps the materials manager to exercise selective
control and focus his attention
only on a few items when he is confronted with lakhs of stores
items. By concentrating on high valued ‘A’
items, the manager will be able to effectively control inventories
and show the ‘visible’, results in a short
spen of time by reducing the overall working capital requirement
and increasing the profit of the company.
By this analysis obsolete stocks are automatically pin pointed.
This results in better planning and improved
inventory turnover.
The major limitation of the ABC analysis is that it takes into
account the total consumption value of
items but not their vitality. Some items, though negligible in
monitory value, may be vital for running the
plant or machines. For example, the connecting belts in case of
motors, foundation bolts etc. the results of
ABC analysis have to be reviewed periodically and updated. Low
valued item in ‘C’ category, like diesel oil
to ruin the generator, may become B for A category item during the
power crises.
5B. 11 VED analysis
This analysis attempts to classify items into many categories
depending upon the consequences of
materials stock out when demanded. The cost of storage may vary
depending upon the seriousness of
such a situation. The items are classified into V (Vital), E
(Essential) and D (Desirable) categories. Vital
items are the most critical having extremely high opportunity cost
of shortage and must be available in
stock when demanded. Essential items are quite critical with
substantial cost associated with shortage and
should be available in stock and by and large. Desirable group of
items do not have very serious
consequences if not available when demanded but can be stocked
items.
Hence, the percentage risk of shortage with the ‘vital’ items has
to be quite small, thus calling for
high level of stock. With ‘Essential category we can take a
relatively high risk of shortage and for
‘Desirable’ category even higher. So, depending upon the
seriousness of the requirement of the item they
are classified.
5B. 12 FSN ANALYSIS
The items that are being used in a company are note required to be
purchased at the same
frequency. Some materials are quite regularly required, yet some
others are required very occasionally and
some materials may have become absolute and might not have been
demanded for years together. This
FSN analysis groups then into three categories as fast moving.
Slow-moving and Non-moving items.
Inventory policies and models for he three categories have to be
different. Most spare parts come under
the slow moving category which has to be managed on a different
basis. For non-moving dead stock, we
have to determine optimal stock disposal procedures and rules
rather than inventory provisioning rules.
Categorization of materials into three types on values, critically
and usage enables us to adopt the right
type of inventory policy to suit a particular situation.
5B. 13 ECONOMIC ORDER QUANTITY (EOQ)
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
FIGURE : 5.6 ECONOMIC BATCH QUANTITY
FIGURE 5.7 ECONOMIC ORDER QUANTITY
Inventories are built to act as a cushion between supply and
demand. The supply could be a one time
supply (static) or a continuously repetitive one (dynamic). The
demand could be totally known (certain), be
known over a range of probable values (risks) or be totally
unknown (uncertain). The goal of the basic EOQ
model is to identify the order size that will minimize the sum of
the annual costs of holding inventory and
the annual cost of ordering inventory. The major elements of the
inventory carrying cost are:
i. opportunity cost of the funds utilized for the purchase of
items
ii. cost incurred in the storage of these items
iii) obsolescence and deterioration cost
iv) insurance cost when items are bought and stored in the
company’s stores
The ideal inventory movement pattern for a given material a
company can be drawn.
The inventory cycle begins with receipt of an order of Q units.
These items are utilized for producing
certain product as a constant rate over a period of time. When the
quantity on hand is not sufficient to
satisfy demand during the lead time (the time requirement between
submitting an order and receiving that
order), an order for Q units is submitted to the supplier. Because
it is assumed that both the usage rate
and the lead time dot not vary, the order will be received at the
precise instant that the inventory on hand
falls to zero. Thus, orders are timed to avoid having excess stock
on hand and to avoid stock outs.
The optimum order quantity reflects a trade off between inventory
carrying costs and ordering costs. as
order size in varied one type of cost will increase while the
other one decreases. The ideal solution will be
an order size that causes neither a few large orders or many small
orders but one that lies somewhere
between those two extremes.
Annual carrying cost is computed by multiplying the average amount
of inventory on hand by the cost to
carry one unit for an year, even though any given unit would not
be held for a year. The average inventory
is one half of the order quantity, the amount on hand decreases
steadily form the maximum of Q units to
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
0, for an average of (Q+O)/2 or Q/2. The average annual carrying
cost per unit is expressed as C, the total
annual carrying cost is calculated as.
Annual carrying cost = Q/2 C
On the other hand, annual ordering cost will decrease as order
size increases, since for a given annual
demand, the larger the order size, the fewer the number of orders needed.
The hunger of orders per year
will be D/Q where D = Annual and Q = order size. Unlike inventory
carrying costs, ordering costs are
relatively incentive to order size in that regardless of the
amount of an order, there are certain activities
which must be done, such as determine how much is needed,
periodically evaluate sources of supply, and
prepare the invoice. Annual ordering cost is a function of the
number of orders per year and the ordering
cost per order:
Annual ordering cost = D/Q S
Where S = ordering cost
Because the number of orders per year, D/Q, decreases as Q
increases, annual ordering cost is
inversely related to order size.
The total annual cost associated with carrying and ordering
inventory when Q@ units are ordered each
time is
TC = Annual carrying cost + Annual ordering cost
= Q/2 C + D/2 S
Where D = Demand in unit per year
Q = Order quantity in units
S = Order cost in rupees
C = Carrying cost in rupees per unit per year.
The total cost curve is U and that it reaches its minimum at the
quantity where carrying and
ordering costs are equal.
To minimize the total cost, differentiate TC with respect to Q and
equating is to 0,
We will get:
Optimum Order Quantity: Q = (√ 2DS) / C
We can calculate the ordering cost per order and the annual carrying
cost per unit, the optimum
(economic) order quantity can be computed if the annual demand is
given.
The minimum total cost is,
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
TC min = Q/2. C + D/Q. S
5B. 14 INVENTORY CONTROL OF SPARES
The spares are required for the upkeep of various general and
special purpose equipment and
machineries in a company. The requirement of spares will emerge
preventive or breakdown maintenance
operations. The requirement of spares can be well planned in the
case of items required during routine
preventive operations irrespective of its cost, critically or its
essentiality. In the case of breakdown of
certain machineries, the requirement of spares becomes critical
for the repair and rectification of the
machinery. If the machine itself as an important special purpose
machinery, then the requirement and
availability of the spares at that point of time is very much
vital irrespective of the cost of the spare. The
required item may fall in any of the A,B,C category, but its
availability is to be ensured by stocking certain
expected items to the required numbers. The inventory control of
spares items call for a trade – off
between the cost of the spares stored and the breakdown or
stoppage of production because o f the
non-availability of certain critical and vital spare parts.
**********
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
5C. NETWORK
5C.1 INTRODUCTION
Operations managers must plan organize and control a variety of
manufacturing and service
operations. Some or they are one time activities and others are
repetitive. Besides, some activities might be
continuous or intermittent or job shop production required
scheduling, loading and control techniques
whereas continuous production requires line balancing techniques.
The one-time activities are generally
one-time projects such as construction of a hospital, research and
development of a missile or
manufacturing an aircraft or building a ship and the like. A
different approach known as project approach
is used to develop, manufacture and market new products and
services.
5C. 2 WHAT IS A PROJECT
Project is a term which covers once-through and small –batch
programmes. When attempting to determine
the completion data for nay task/project. Where it is
Construction projects, building of a bridge etc.
Research and development Projects
Designing of a new pieces of equipment
Erection and commission of Industrial Plants
Preventive maintenance
Trial manufacture.
Heavy engineering
Custom-engineered Products
Market launching of new Products
Finalization of annual accounts
An inaugural
A banquet
A marriage programme
Preparation for a dinner party
A picnic party
A picnic outing etc.
Or any other project it is necessary to time-table all the
activities which make up the task or the project,
that is to say, a plan must be prepared. The need for planning has
always been present, but the
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
complexity and competitiveness of modern undertaking now requires
that this need should be met rather
than just recognized.
5C. 3 PROJECT MANAGEMENT
A project is an organized endeavour to accomplish a specified
non-routine or low volume task. Although
projects are not repetitive, they take significant amount of time
to complete and are large-scale or
complex enough to be recognized and managed as separate
undertakings.
Management of a project differs in several ways from management of
a typical business.
Operations manager must often organize project team to plan and
control projects. The objective of a
project team is to accomplish its assigned mission and disband.
The project teams must ordinarily work to
tight time schedules, adhere to strict budgets, report to top
management personnel of the organisatoin
and be temporarily removed from their regular jobs. While the
project work is proceeding, the remainder
of the organisation must continue to produce the organisation’s
products. Because of the difficulty of
simultaneously managing the projects and producing the products
and services, operations manages have
developed new approaches to managing and controlling projects. The
type of techniques required to
manage the projects depndss on the complexity of the projects. For
small projects, Gantt chats are
adequate whereas for large and complex projects, the critical path
method (CPM) or the program
evaluation and review technique (PERT) would be more effective.
In this architect’s office, representatives from human resources
and product management bring their skills
together from their “home” departments to complete this facility
expansion. Workmanship, pleasure from
job flexibility, and pride in the team effort. All of these can be
fostered and encouraged by project
managers.
5C. 4 CONVERSION SYSTEM: PROGRESS REPORTING
Project management involves more than just planning, it also
requires controlling, monitoring
progress and taking corrective action when activities deviate from
schedules or costs get out of line.
Progress reporting helps managers control by showing cost
variances (actual versus budgeted) and time
variance (actual versus scheduled) during the projects.
5C. 5 MATRIX ORGANIZATION
The matrix organization is a team approach to special projects.
When teams are established, the
firm’s organization departs from the conventional functional basis
a for organization –
departmentalization.
Today, project teams enjoy widespread acceptance in many of our
major industries. They are especially
effective in large companies that emphasize new product
development and rapid launching of new
products in the marketplace.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Several factors seem to have been responsible for this trend
toward project teams. Rapid technological
changes forced organizations to minimize development lead times,
reduce costs, and avoid obsolescence.
There pressures resulted in the need for a kind of organization
that could cut across functional areas. The
project matrix organization fills that need. Engineers,
scientists, technicians, market specialists, and other
skilled personnel can be effectively and efficiently loaned from
their “home” unit to another unit for
periods of time, thus avoiding duplicated skills and unnecessary
costs.
5C. 6 BEHAVIORS IN A PROJECT ENVIRONMENT
Project manages must not only be competent technically but must
also be skilled in analysis,
interpersonal relations, and decision making. Let’s briefly
examine a few key behaviours within project
teams.
5C. 7 COMMUNICATION
Project leaders must be able to communicate freely with both team
members and line employees
who are not regular team members. Within the project team, communication
is frequent and often involves
intensive collaboration Short daily meetings, written
correspondence, and one-on-one problem-solving
sessions are often necessary for the sort of tasks required of
project teams. The non routine, diverse,
loosely structured tasks that project teams often engage in
require flexible relationships and
communications to avoid duplication of effort and costly project
delays.
5C. 8 MOTIVATION
Project managers motivate team members in much the same way other
manages motivate their
staff Motivation comes from either extrinsic of intrinsic rewards.
One difficulty a project manages may face
is they may not have sufficient latitude to give monetary rewards.
They may be able, however, to give
monetary rewards in the form of incentives for cost control and
completion time. Or hey may rely on
intrinsic rewards, such as satisfaction from tasks accomplished,
pride in quality.
5C. 9 GROUP COHESIVENESS
As the size of the project team increases, group cohesiveness
decreases. The higher a group ranks
in organization status (measured by project importance, skills
required, and job flexibility), the more
cohesive the group tends to be. If group members’ social economic
or psychological needs are met by a
group, they tend to feel strong ties to the group. The more a
project team fills these needs, the more
cohesive the team. Finally, the closer group members work in close
proximity to one another under stress
conditions, the greater the groups cohesiveness.
Overall, the more cohesive the group, the better the chances a
project can be completed on budget
and on time. Because of both the diversity of team members and the
one-shot nature of the project, group
cohesiveness is difficult to achieve in project teams. But project
teams that are cohesive increase their
chance of achieving their primary goals.
5C. 10 PROJECT LIFE CYCLE
A project passes through a life cycle that may vary with the size
and complexity of the project.
Typically an project will pass through the following phases:
1. The Concept Phase: During this phase, the organization realizes
that a project may be needed or
the organisation is requested to propose a plan to perform a
project for some customer.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
2. Initial Planning of Feasibility phase: During this phase, the
project manager plans the project to a
level of detail, sufficient for initial scheduling and budgeting.
3. Detailed Planning Phase: If the project is approved, then
detailed scheduling and budgeting is done
in this phase.
4. Organisation Phase: During this phase, a detailed project
definition such as the work breakdown
structure (WBS) is examined. A WBS is a document similar to the
bill of material and divides the
total work into major packages to be accomplished.
Personal and other resources necessary to accomplish the project
are then made available for all or
a portion of the projects duration through temporary assignments
from other parts of the
organisatoin or by leasing resources or subcontracting portions of
the projects.
5. Execution Phase: During this phase the various activities
planned are completed as per the
schedule, utilizing the allotted resources.
6. Termination Phase: This is the phase, during which the project
is terminated or disbanded after
completion. The personnel who were working in the project are
assigned back to their regular jobs
or to other jobs in the organisation or to other projects in this
phase.
5C. 11 PROJECT ORGANIZATION
Project organizations have been developed to ensure both
continuity of the production system in
its day to day activities and the successful completion of
projects. A variety of organizational structure are
used by enterprises to perform project work. The various
considerations in forming a project organisation
are:
(a) Proportion of the company’s work that is performed by projects
(b) The scope and duration of the projects
(c) The capabilities of the available personnel
(d) The preferences of the decision makers
There are four options available in choosing an appropriate
organization for project.
1. Functional organization: in functional organizations,
functional departments are formed that
specialize in a particular type of work such as production and
sales. These functional departments
often are broken into smaller units that focus on special areas
within the function. Top
management may divide project into work tasks and assign them to
the appropriate functional
units. The project is then budgeted and managed through the normal
management hierarchy.
2. Project co-ordinator: A project may be handled through the
organisation as described above,
except some one is appointed to co-ordinate the project. The
project is still funded through the
normal organization and he functional manages retain
responsibility and authority to their portion
of the project work. The project co-ordinator meets with the
functional managers and provides
focus and impetus for the project and may report its status to the
top management.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
3. Project matrix: In a matrix organisation, a project manager is
responsible for completion of the
project and often assigned a budget. The project manager contracts
with the functional managers
for completion of specified parts of the project. The functional
managers for completion of
specified parts of the project. The functional managers assign
work to employees and co-ordinate
work within their areas. The project managers co-ordinates project
efforts across the functional
units.
4. Project Team: A particularly significant project that will have
a long duration and require the full
time efforts of a group may be run by a project team, specially
constituted for that purpose.
Personnel are assigned full-time to the project and are physically
located with other team members.
The project has its own management structure and budget as though
it were a separate division of
the company.
5C. 12 THE ROLE OF A PROJECT MANAGERS
The project manager’s job is important and challenging. He is
responsible for getting work
performed, but often has no direct, formal authority over must of
the people who perform the work. He
must often rely on broader knowledge of the project and skills at
negotiation and persuasion to influence
participants. He may have the assistance of a staff if the project
is large.
5C. 13 PROJECT ORGANISATOIN : ADVANTAGES
Perhaps the one overriding advantage of project organization is
that by grouping people and tasks,
the organization can tackle unusual project opportunities on short
notice. A key disadvantage, however, is
that creating and dispersing project teams can be upsetting to the
routine employees have developed.
Furthermore, project manages often feel considerable constraints
in having to accept responsibility for
completing the project without being given line authority to
control it.
5C. 14 BASIC FUNCTIONS OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT
1. Manage the project’s scope to define the goals and work to be
done, in sufficient detail to facilitate
understanding and correct performance by the participants.
2. Manage the human resources involved in the project
3. Manage-communications to see that, the appropriate parties are
informed
4. Manage time by planning and meeting a schedule
5. Manage – quality so that, the project’s results are
satisfactory
6. Manage-costs so that, the project is performed at the minimum
practical cost and within budget if
possible.
5C. 15 PROBLEMS IN MANAGING A PROJECT
1. Managing a project can be a complex and challenging assignment.
2. Since projects are one-of-a-kind endeavors, there may be little
in the way of experience, normal
working relationships or established procedures to guide
participants.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
3. A project managers may have to co-ordinate diverse efforts and
activities to achieve the project
goals.
4. Persons from various disciplines and from various parts of the
organization who have never worked
together may be assigned to the project for differing spans of
time.
5. Sub-contractors who are unfamiliar with the organisation may be
brought in to carry out major
portions of the project.
6. The project may involve a large number of inter-related
activities performed by persons employed
by any one of several different sub-contractors.
For the above reasons, it is important that the project leaders
have an effective means of identifying and
communicating the planned activities and the way in which they are
to be inter-related. An effective
scheduling and monitoring method is absolutely essential for the
management of a large project. Network
scheduling methods such as, PERT and CPM have proven to be highly
effective and valuable tools during
both the planning and execution phases of projects.
5C. 16 HISTORY OR NET ANALYSIS
Before CPA coming on the scene probably the best-known method of
trying to plan was by mean of a bar
or Gantt chart. There were certain drawbacks and problems in it.
In Great Britain the Operational Research
Section of the Central Electricity Generating Board investigated
the Problems concerned with the overhauls
of Generating Plant – an area of considerably complexity which was
increasing in importance as new higher
Performance Plant was being brought into service. By 1957 the O.R.
section had devised a technique which
consisted essentially of identifying the “Longest irreducible
sequence of events”, and using this technique
they carried out in 1958 an experimental overhaul at a Power
Station which reduced to overall time on 42%
of the previous average time for the same work. Continuing to work
upon these times the overhaul time
was further reduced by 1960 to 32% of the previous average time.
The name, “Longest irreducible by
sequence of events” was soon replace by the name, “Major Sequence,
and it was pointed out for example,
that delay in the “major-sequence” would delay completion times,,
but the difficulties elsewhere need not
necessarily involve extension in total time. This work of the O.R.
group was not made public, although
comprehensive reports were circulated internally elsewhere.
Similar development work was being undertaken elsewhere – for
example in the U.S. Air force
under the code name P.E.P. Also in 1958, the E.I. du pont de
Nemours Company used a technique called
the “Critical Path Method” “CPM” to schedule and control a very
large project, and during the first complete
year’s Use of CPM it was credited with credited with saving the
company $ 1 million. Subsequent use
underlined the basic, simplicity and extra-ordinary usefulness of
this method, and by 1959 Dr. Machly,
who had worked on the Du Pont Project, set up an organisation to
solve industrial problems using the
Critical Path Method.
Since 1958 considerable work has been carried out, mainly in the
United States of America, in
consolidating and improving these techniques. Much of the effort
has been expanded by the Computer
Companies, who have devised special names to distinguish their own
work.
Network analysis is synthesis of two techniques namely Programme
Evaluation and Review
Technique and Critical Path Method evolved independently during
1956-57. The two methods have many
features in common and are now combined and called Network
Analysis. For large non-repetitive
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
operations or projects CPM-PERT and other related network
technique are usefully aids for project
managers. A few of the features making the techniques are:
A logical and disciplined basis for planning
Simplicity
Improves co-ordination and communication
Pinpoints trouble spots and responsibility
Better management of resources
Versatile and application
Scope for unseen changes
5C. 17 ORIGIN OF NETWORK PLANNING
The very nature of the one-time large project demands that what
has to be done and the schedule
for performance must be planned together. These factors are
interdependent, and the planning of large
projects involves planning for deployment of resources to the
total project. To accomplish this, we must
determine the activities required, the timing and
interdependencies, the requirements of various possible
schedules for manpower and other resources, and the relationship
of all the foregoing to a project
completion date. The project completion date most often is part of
a contract that carries penalties for
nonperformance. Therefore, the complexities and the one-time
nature of the project require a coordinated
plan that involves activities required, scheduling, and deployment
of resources. The great complexity of
such projects calls for special methods; network planning
techniques have been developed to meet this
need.
Network planning techniques go under a confusion of actronyms with
variations. The two original names.
PERT (Performance Evaluation and Review Technique) and CPM
(Critical Path Methods), have been
differentiated into a variety of brand names that essentially have
been applied to the same basic
methodology. Some of the alternative names used are: CPS (Critical
Path Scheduling), LES (Least-cost
Estimating and Scheduling)(, Micro-PERT, 1-Time-PERT, PERT/COST
and PEP. The variety of names for
PERT/CPM techniques are a measure of the degree of interest that
has developed.
Network planning methods seem to have been developed by two
different groups independently. As an
internal project of the DuPont Company, critical path methods were
developed to plan and control the
maintenance of chemical plants; subsequently the were used widely
by DuPont for many engineering
functions. Parallel efforts were undertaken by the U.S. Navy at
about the same time to develop method for
planning and controlling the Poiaris missile project. We can
glimpse the magnitude of the task when we
realize that approximately 3,000 separate contracting organization
were involved. The result was the
development of the PERT methodology. The immediate success of both
the CPM and PERT methodologies
may be gauged by the following facts. Do Pont’s application of its
technique to a Louisville maintenance
project resulted in reducing down time for maintenance from 125 to
78 hours, the PERT technique was
credited widely with helping to shorten by 2 years the time
originally estimated for the completion of the
Polaris missile engineering and development program.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
PERT and CPM are based on substantially the same concepts,
although there are some differences in
details. First, as originally developed, the PERT methods were
based on probabilistic estimates of activity
times that resulted in a probabilistic path through a network of
activities and a probabilistic project
completion time. The CPM methods, however, assumed constant or
deterministic activity times, and they
now use the slightly simpler deterministic model is equally
applicable to and usable by either technique.
As a matter of fact, most present day applications of PERT methods
have dropped the use of the
probabilistic activity times estimates. The second difference
between the two techniques is in the detail of
how the arrow diagram is prepared. In the discussion that follows,
we shall note more fully both the
probabilistic – deterministic and the arrow diagram differences.
In the following sections, we shall develop PERT planning methods
and then show the difference between
PERT and CPM methods.
5B. 18 UTILITY OF NETWORKS
1. It aids the manager in planning, scheduling, controlling the
activities.
2. In guiding and directing team efforts more effectively
3. It permits advance planning, indicates current progress wants
of potential future trouble spots
when there may still be time to avoid them.
4. It aids in handling uncertainties regarding time schedules,
co-ordination of many activities and
control of cost involved.
5. It shows its values most strikingly when a special projects of
new kind is undertaken.
5C. 19 NETWORK TECHNIQUES OF PROGRAM MANAGEMENT
The need for management direction on a program or job depends upon
two factors-its
repetitiveness and complexity. Simple jobs that occur infrequently
do not require any involved direction.
The techniques for direction of project-type jobs are the new.
However, there has recently been an
explosive growth in the family of these technique a number of
network techniques have been developed
which are named below:
(1) PERT :Programme Evaluation and Review Technique
(2) CPM : Critical Path Method
5C. 20 PROJECT PLANNING AND CONTROL TECHNIQUES
PROJECT PLANNING: Project planning includes all activities that
result in a course of action for a
project. Planning begins with setting well defined objectives
(such as implementing an new management
information system). Also, planning involves decision making
regarding resources to be committed,
completion times, priorities of activities etc. Areas of
responsibility must be identified and assigned. Time
and resource requirements to perform the work activities must be
forecasted and budgeted. Planning also
involves establishing project boundaries and identifying
controllable and uncontrollable variables that
must be managed. Also, the performance criteria should be stated
related to the project objectives and in
measures of time, cost and quality characteristics.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
PROJECT SCHEDULING: Project scheduling establishes times and
sequences of the various phases of
the project. In project scheduling, the project manager considers
the various activities of an overall project
and the tasks that must be accomplished and relates them
coherently to one another over the projects
time horizon.
Techniques for scheduling projects include Gantt charts and
network techniques such as PERT and
CPM. Gantt Charts do not reflect the inter-relationship among
resources or the precedence relationships
among project activities. Network technique overcome this
shortcoming of Gantt charts by including
precedence relationships.
5C. 21 DEVELOPMENT OF PERT
Project Managers increasingly noted that the technique of
Frederick Taylor and Henry L. Gantt
introduce during the early part of he century for large scale
productions, were inapplicable for a large
portion of the industrial effort. The work was being undertaken in
the U.S.A. and in early 1958 the U.S.
Navy Special Project. Office concerned with performance tends on
large military development programs set
up team of the management consulting firm of Booz-Allen and
Hamilton; to devise a means of dealing
with the planning and subsequent control of complex work. This
investigation was known as the
Programme Evaluation Research Task, which gave rise to (or
possible derived from) the code name PERT.
By February 1958, Dr. C.E. Clark, mathematical in the PERT team
presented the early notions of
arrow-diagramming, military drawing from his study of graphics.
This early work of Dr. Clark was rapidly
published and by July 1958, the firs report, PERT Summary Report,
phase I, was published. By this time the
full title of the work had become “Programme Evaluation and Review
Technique”, and the value of the
technique seemed well established.
FIGURE: 5.8 “PERT” – A SAMPLE
By October, 1958, it was decided to apply PERT to the Fleet
Ballistic Missiles Programmes where it was
credited with saving two years in the development of Polaris
Missile. Since that time PERT has spread
rapidly through out the U.S. defence and Space industry Currently
almost every major Government and
military agency concerned with space Age Programs is utilizing the
technique as large industrial contractor
in this field. Small business wishing to participate in national
defence programs has found it increasingly
necessary to develop PERT capability.
In 1958 the U.S. Navy developed Program Evaluation and Review
Technique (PERT) for planning
and control of the Polaris nuclear submarine project. The results
of using PERT in that application, in which
some 3,000 contractors were involved, is generally reported to
have reduced by two years the project
completion time for the Polaris project in both government and
industry today, PERT is still widely used. A
similar modeling approach called the Critical Path Method (CPM) is
also used by business and government.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
5C. 22 Application of PERT
First we should clarify the conditions under which PERT may be
appropriately used. If your situation
lacks the following features, PERT will yield little benefit.
First, the project must be one whose activities
clearly are distinct and separable. Second, the project and
activities must all have clear starting and ending
dates. Third, the project must not be complicate by too many
interrelated tasks. Fourth, the project must
be one whose activities afford alternative sequencing and timing.
5C. 23 LANGUAGE OF ‘PERT’
Symbol Name Meaning
Activity
FIGURE : 5.10 PERT – A GLOSSARY
The PERT language comprise simple symbols and terms. Key symbols
are those for activity, dummy
activity, event, and critical path of the network. Since the
critical path requires the longest time through
the network, management should watch is most closely to avoid
unnecessary project delays.
5C. 24 HOW DOES PERT WORK
It works by following these steps:
Clearly identify all activities in the project
Identify the precedence requirements of the activities
Diagram the precedence requirements as a sequence of activities
Estimate the time each activity will take.
Calculate the critical path and other project performance
criteria, creating the schedule and plan for
subsequent control.
Reevaluate and revise as experience dictates.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Time estimates are obtained form either past data or from people
experimented in a particular activity.
Optimistic, pessimistic and most likely times must be estimated so
that the expected (average) time can be
calculated from the following equation.
5C. 25 ADVANTAGES OF PERT
It provides clear objectives
It provides an analytical approach to the achievements of an
objective
It enumerates detailed plans and important programmes and events
It establishes sequence of activities and their inter
relationship.
It focuses attention on important and critical activities and
events.
It provides a logical plan for formulating a realistic schedule of
activities.
It provides up-to-date status information of the project and
enables quick revive of the progress at
all stages
It can point out improbabilities and may even predict be fore
their occurrence and they help to
remedy the situation.
It can foretell the feasibility of a plan and can help in
formulating new schedules if the one under
consideration is found impracticable or wanting.
It avoids slippage of plan and waste of time, energy and money
It is an aid for allocating the available resources for optimum
results.
It brings about time and cost consciousness at all levels of
management
5C. INTRODUCTION “PERT” INTO AN ORGANIZATION
As with any other new managerial tool, PERT will require to be
introduced into an organisation with
care. It is suggested that the following points should be
observed.
1. PERT is not a universal tool – there are situations where it
cannot be usefully employed. These
situations are, in general those where activity is Continuous, for
example, flow production. A PERT
type situation is characteristically on which has a definable
start and definable finish.
2. PERT is not a life saving drug, it does not cure all ills –
Indeed, PERT in itself does not solve any
problems, but it does expose situations in a way which will
presuit effective examinations both of
the problems and of the effect of possible solutions. How ever.
The formulating and implementing
of nay solution will remain the responsibility of the appropriate
manager.
PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
3. PERT must not be made a mystery, known only toa chosen few. All
levels require to appreciate the
method and its limitations, an extensive educational programme
will be necessary to ensure that
knowledge is spread as widely as possible.
4. The person initiating PERT into an organisation must be of
sufficient stature and maturity to be
able to influence both senior and junior personnel.
5. Wherever possible, the early applications for PERT should be to
simple situations. If PERT is first
employed on a very difficult task, it may fail, not because of the
difficulty of PERT but because of
the difficulty of he task itself.
However, the failure is likely to be attributed to PERT and the
technique will be discredited.
6. PERT will involve committal to, and the acceptance of,
responsibilities expressed in qualitative
terms. Many supervisors find this difficult to accept, and will
often try to escape by creating unreal
problems, it is vital to make it quite clear that PERT is not a
punitive device; it is a tool to assist, not
a weapon to assault.
7. Difficulties in using PERT are almost always symptoms of same
Managerial Weakness.
5C. 27 PERT PLANNING METHODS
The essence of PERT planning is based on the development of a
network representation of the
required activities. Here, the arrows represent the required
activities coded by the letters with estimated
performance time shown near the arrows. In network planning, the
length of the arrows ordinarily has no
significance. The numbered circles define the beginning and end
points of activities and are called events
or nodes. The direction of arrows indicate flow.
5C. 28 STEPS IN ‘PERT’ PLANNING
Define clearly the end objectives.
Determine the major events that must be completed prior to
reaching the end objectives.
Analyses and record the work to be done in between events.
The project is broken down into different activities
systematically.
Arrange the events and activities in the order of sequence of
their occurrence.
The network diagram is drawn. Events and activities are numbered
and make sure no activity is left
over.
Layout and finalize the network in a neat form. May be more than
one attempt is needed.
Event numbers should be given with the starting event as I, and
progressing successively to the
right in the order in which they occur.
Any dummy activity should be shown by dotted arrow time on the
network.
No comments:
Post a Comment